agnes the alien!

I'm Agnes, and I'll be your Twitter Lolcow for the week!

Hey, I'm Agnes. I run Sunset Archive, a fork of the software behind Archive of Our Own, the largest fanfiction site in the world. Recently, said large fanfiction site went down for several weeks. In the meantime, I have been called:

And more!

Why? Well, I run a fanfiction site. My fanfiction site is for works centered around sapphic relationships; F/F, F/NB, and NB/NB couples. Except I used to allow F/F/M if the focus was on the female characters more than the man. This was for cases in which, for example, the FF couple were also dating a man who is mentioned but not in the fic, or an FF couple with a shared history involving a male character, or threesomes where the two characters are actually thinking about each other the whole time, etc. It was also something I was harassed into adding around the beginning of the site. I added it because I figured if I did the harassment would stop, and I figured that the site was small enough I could moderate it appropriately. Up until the AO3 shutdown, this was indeed the case.

I closed the invite queue when we were getting about 20 requests a minute. We ballooned in size, tripled our user count in 3 days. We went viral on…

Okay, take a step back. I want you to guess.

I want you to guess what site we went viral on that lead to this harassment.

Go on. Guess.

Yeah, it was Twitter. You got it in one, right?

People REALLY DID NOT LIKE that I wasn't telling men to fuck off and go kill themselves. I tried discussing this with people in good faith on my barely-touched account and got told that me forgetting to include that F/F/M was allowed on the content policy page had been an intentionally malicious male-brained move. Which… okay, yeah, that was an oversight! But nothing more than an oversight. How many of the people harassing me were neurodivergent and could not consider for one second that I might have simply forgotten to add it? I don't know.

I think what bothered me most, though, was the people asking what the point of my site is. Why have Sunset when AO3 exists? (Nevermind that AO3 was inaccessible at the time.) "I give it 3 days", people said, even though we'd been around over a year at that point. There are filters on AO3, just filter out M/M.

Did anyone consider that Sunset might not be just another place to dump fics for transactional attention, that with Sunset I am instead attempting to create a community of like-minded people, where we can discuss female characters and F/F in a space where our voices won't get drowned out or called annoying, where WE come first and aren't an afterthought? Did anyone consider that Sunset is an attempt at forming a web that isn't hostile to femslash shippers? A true archive of our own? That I want more than users who only come on to post fics and never engage with anything else?

I don't think anyone even comprehends that fandom is supposed to be community anymore. I think people see fandom as a PvP battleground where nothing you say matters because it's all over the internet. Fandom is supposed to be a place of supporting one another. I know, I know, in practice that is very much not always true. But it's supposed to be. When that is practiced appropriately, it can be really beautiful. Fandom has brought me so many beautiful things—love, friendship, opportunities—and fandom has also brought me significant heartache. I still dedicate myself to it because I believe we can have a good, positive, and kind fandom space if we try our best. And though I don't always succeed at acting positive myself, I know it is important to do so.

The people in fandom matter more than the fictional characters. I can't believe I have to say this, y'all.

Anyway I realized, during all of this, that it was impossible to moderate F/F/M content any further, and that it was perhaps not in line in its entirety with the goals of the site, so I disallowed it going forward. My existing F/F/M writers actually understood and supported me in this decision. A few people on Twitter continued harassing me for it, insisting I was then homophobic and only wanted to allow content I deemed "sapphic Enough". No one considered that I too may have been called not sapphic Enough as a nonbinary lesbian countless times and that my intentions were not to censor but rather to ease my own stressors with moderation. And you know what?

Not a single person - not a SINGLE person - reached out to me and kindly told me that I might want to reconsider allowing F/F/M content on Sunset. We got lots of people reaching out to ask me to ban icky gross stuff, and they were nice—because they assumed I would give in to them after banning F/F/M (they were very very wrong.) But no one actually talked to me about this. No one emailed. No one asked me on Discord or our Tumblr. Absolutely nothing. No one gave me any suggestions, only assumptions and hatred.

When I finally banned it, I made the mistake of saying this in the announcement post: "I have come to an unfortunate decision." God forbid you not enjoy upsetting and disappointing your users! I was then dogpiled for using the word "unfortunate."

One reddit user wrote:

"Didn't she call the decision to block dick "unfortunate'?"

(I do not entertain the idea whatsoever that anyone at all involved in this conversation would gender me correctly.)

I don't get sadistic joy out of banning things. I love my users, the people who support me, and I was upset that I had to tell them they weren't allowed to post some of their content anymore; I never should've made that rule of inclusion in the first place, it was my mistake. I was upset I had made so many mistakes in the content policy overall. I caved when I shouldn't have, back then when I decided to allow it. I was mad at myself. And, in the shaky midst of my mental breakdown, I used the wrong word. The absolute fucking horror.

Misinformation was spread. I found out my logo "artist" may have used AI through an anonymous message someone sent to another person that said "Sunset Archive is AI btw :/". I am now working with an artist I know for a fact isn't AI to make a new logo for us. But man, the fact that we ban AI in our content policy should've given you a clue that I didn't know. No one can take anyone in good faith these days. I know people use AI and lie about it and it's hard to trust, but… ugh. It's just. There's no winning! No one could take me in good faith!?!? Really???

The worst of it was being spread around a TERF subreddit, being torn apart for my chosen pronouns, my very existence, as well as the fact that I don't hate trans women. I am PROUD of Sunset's inclusive ideals and I am proud, most of all, of all our transfem users. I took steps to ensure people know where I stand with Sunset—I added a statement telling TERFs to get out underneath the header on every page. But the damage is done, they know about my site, and I had to turn guest comments off because they started targeting my users. Make fun of me, whatever, but don't go after the people on my site, you fucking ghouls. Be miserable somewhere else. It aches to know I was the cause of some people getting transphobic hate, even if indirectly.

But it hasn't been all bad. I have found tons and tons of new users. I had tons of people offer support and kindness and help with the invite queue when it was being swamped. I get ten emails a day asking to join and I don't know how to say no to them. I can't let people in until the TERF bullshittery dies down, I just can't; I'm too gullible and trusting so there has to be an overall rule. I do allow existing members to invite people, but I cannot make that call myself at the moment, and it makes me feel so bad!

I keep getting messages from people who live in countries that are very unsupportive of queer folk saying that they find my site to be a haven, that they find comfort in Sunset. That is who I run Sunset for. I run Sunset for the people who need to be seen and heard. I want to make people feel like they can "ride off into the Sunset" and not be afraid of judgement or lesbophobia. I run Sunset for the femslash fans who give a raw, visceral fuck, not for the "wholesome yuri ONLY!" Twitter fans. I welcome all, of course, as long as you are respectful! But I run Sunset because I am genuinely passionate, and as such I want my users to genuinely be passionate too.

I don't know. I've been in fandom since I was 10, so I guess I'm overdue for a cancellation. I am just hoping this bullshit introduced Sunset to at least one person who will enjoy and benefit from it. That's all I want—to make a difference in fandom.

fandom, sunset, personal

⬅ Previous post
Knowvember '26